Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
A charming, offbeat love story set to music on the streets of NYC. An intimate and irresistible Broadway musical at the Longacre Theatre.
From $74
104 performances available
- Official tickets
- Pick your own seats
- Full refund if your event is cancelled
More ticket options
Resale via VividSeats · from $85About this show
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) Tickets
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) brings a charming romantic comedy musical to Broadway's Longacre Theatre. The story follows an optimistic British visitor who arrives in New York to meet the father he's never known, only to be paired with a sharp, guarded New Yorker for what should be a simple favour. One wedding cake later, they find themselves pulled through the neighbourhoods, family tensions, and emotional blind spots of a single New York day.
Written by Jim Barne and Kit Buchan, this witty musical stars Olivier Award winner Sam Tutty (Dear Evan Hansen) as Dougal and Christiani Pitts (A Bronx Tale, King Kong) as Robin. Under Tim Jackson's direction and choreography, the story unfolds through clever songwriting and an imaginative suitcase-driven set that keeps the city constantly shifting around the characters. The show runs for 2 hours 15 minutes with an interval and is suitable for ages 12 and above.
Highlights
- Olivier Award winner Sam Tutty delivers standout performance alongside Christiani Pitts in this feel-good Broadway musical
- Imaginative staging transforms stacks of silver suitcases into the landmarks and neighbourhoods of New York City
- Witty songwriting from Jim Barne and Kit Buchan explores themes of family, chance meetings, and unexpected connections
- Acclaimed 2023 Off West End premiere at the Kiln Theatre brings fresh energy to Broadway at the Longacre Theatre
- Popular songs include "New York", "First Date/Last Date", and the title track "Carry a Cake"
- Critics celebrate the show's humour, candid emotion, and chemistry between the leads
Plan Your Visit to Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) runs at the Longacre Theatre from 20 November 2025 to 6 July 2026. Evening performances typically start at 7 PM or 8 PM, with matinee shows usually on Wednesdays and Saturdays at 2 PM. Arrive at least 30 minutes before showtime to allow for entry and finding your seats.
The Longacre Theatre offers wheelchair accessibility, accessible restrooms, companion seating, and assistive listening devices. Smart casual or semi-formal attire is recommended. Mobile phones must be switched off during the performance, and photography or recording is not permitted. If you're exploring more Broadway shows, consider checking out other musicals in New York or discover what else is playing at venues throughout the Theatre District.
Late arrivals may not be admitted until a suitable break in the performance, so plan your journey accordingly. The theatre has restrooms and drinking water fountains available. For theatre lovers looking to make the most of their New York visit, you might also enjoy exploring Broadway theatre district tours to learn more about the history and stories behind the famous venues.
Good to know
Next available · Tue, Aug 18, 2026
Refund policy
These tickets cannot be cancelled or rescheduled.
What audiences say
Audiences love the energetic and witty storytelling of this charming musical that captures the essence of New York City. Many praise the brilliant performances, clever staging, and the delightful blend of comedy and heartfelt moments. The music and humor resonate, creating a fun and engaging experience for all.
Based on 1,125 audience reviews · 4.5/5 average
What the critics say
“Critic’s Pick: "The effervescent new musical comedy...is the most charmingly simple show on Broadway right now — a stellar debut for its authors... and the actor Sam Tutty.”
“This cake isn’t fully baked...For its staging at the Longacre, with an unnecessary intermission that slams the brakes on the action, the director Tim Jackson has slathered the thing in the icing of sentiment and popped his cork”
“Unfortunately, all that momentum is eventually stymied due to the inevitable conflict that by law must arrive between any couple in a romantic comedy.”
“This is a twee, two-character rom-com that could easily be a Hallmark holiday musical... So while this show held me for Act One with its considerable charm, by Act Two, it was hitting turbulence.”
“We’ve got a brand new Broadway star. His name is Sam Tutty...he’s hilarious, Shirley Temple endearing and effortlessly magnetic as a puppy-dog Englishman who’s just landed in the five boroughs for the first time.”
“This is a charming little show (which definitely doesn’t need to be two hours and twenty minutes long)”
““The greatest assets of this musical are the performances, the entertainment value, and light tone.””
“Infectiously whimsical and sentimental, the show juxtaposes these qualities against a New York reality that has little time for either.”
“The show might refer to itself as a musical comedy, but it is closer to a play with music, and an outstanding one at that.”
“For an optimist, this is a rom-com recipe where familiarity is a feature, not a flaw...is like a warm hot chocolate as respite from the snow.”
“It is an act of prestidigitation: Entertainment and real emotional engagement are pulled out of thin air.”
“Tutty and Pitts do just that and make Two Strangers a terrific feel-good addition to this theater season.”
“a low-key, tuneful, predictable if not entirely formulaic production that relies on the talent and charm of its two youthful performers”
“Two Strangers, spanning two days of personal growth in two hours and 20 minutes (including intermission), is both far too long for the audience’s attention and far too short for Dougal and Robin’s transformations.”
“I hope that they rake in the dough!”
“The melodies are thoroughly listenable and relatable, being worth hearing again, their lyrics always clearly related to the characters and storytelling.”
“Every now and then, an enchanting new musical classic comes along out of nowhere, with pop-tinged bops that are as catchy as Velcro. ‘Two Strangers’ may not follow the template of a traditional love story, but it’s a crush note to a New York City and one of the best new musicals of the year”
Community Reviews
Venue
Longacre Theatre, 220 W 48th St, New York, NY 10036, USA
Other shows you may like
Just In Time
Circle In The Square Theatre · New York
From $94
Maybe Happy Ending
Belasco Theatre · New York
From $56
& Juliet
Stephen Sondheim Theatre · New York
From $75
The Play That Goes Wrong
New World Stages / Stage 4 · New York
From $103
Chicago
Ambassador Theatre · New York
From $81
Little Shop of Horrors
Westside Theatre · New York
From $75
Moulin Rouge! The Musical
Al Hirschfeld Theatre · New York
From $199
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
Lyric Theatre · New York
From $68